Master LU: 070911.2010 {Dates in this format are: YYMMDD.HHmm} http://www.kbsb.com/bonnelltree/john-compare.htm  
LU: 070911.2010 john-compare.htm http://www.KBSB.com/bonnelltree/ slbnl@kbsb.com Steven L Bonnell  
  Lancaster 1729 :>: Dauphin Co 1785;   Northumberland 1772 :>: Lycoming 1795;   Erie 1800      
This is part of an on-going search for added information for the specific      
  John Bonnell, Revolutionary Soldier, that died around Erie, PA about 1845.    
This will be a comparison of data collected concerning several John Bonnell's of the same time period.     
At present, I am aware of  FIVE  John Bonnells that were soldiers in the American Revolution.    
           
  070706   {YYMMDD} 070706 070706 070706 added: 070713
Item: John 1 John 2 John 3 John 4 John 5
Death Date: 1845 15 Dec 1817   [CB] 1 Apr 1823 21 Aug 1808 [CB] 184x  [CB]
Death Location: WATERFORD TWP, ERIE Co, PA SPRINGFIELD TWP. ESSEX Co, NJ HARRISON Co, VA Screven Co, GA   [CB] BERLIN, Wayne Co, PA  [CB]
Grave site: ? Waterford CM - Waterford, PA ? HILLSIDE CM -- MADISON,NJ   [CB]     bethany cem, wayne co., pa
           
Birth Date: 1757 26 Sep 1737   [CB] 1762 ~173x   [CB] 18 Mar 1757 [CB]  Mar 1757  [gb]
Birth Location: ?  New Jersey  -or-  Ireland  ? ELIZABETH ESSEX Co, NJ  HUNTERDON Co, NJ SC   [CB] ESSEX Co, NJ  [gb]
           
Wife: ?  NANCY_ PANDY   (Betsey) (NANCY_FARRADAY)  ? SARAH CARTER b.1737  1) HANNAH SMITH    
2) RHULANA FITZRANDOLPH
Winifred Wilson    [CB]  Nancy Day  [CB]
marriage   m. 1756 Chatham, Morris Co, NJ     m.1779  Essex Co, NJ  [CB]
Children: (1) Thomas 1776-1871;
(
2) John Bonnell, Jr 1780-1874;
(
3) Margaret b.1782; 
(
4) Nancy b.1783 
(
5) George 1786-1870; 
(
6) William S 1788-1878;  
(
7) Sarah b.1790;   
(1) James 1758-1807;
(
2) Nancy 1760-1853;
(
3) Jonathan b.1763;
(
4) Israel 1765-1849;
(
5) Joanna b.1767;
(
6) Hannah b.1770;
(
7) Sylvanus 1773-1825;
(
8) Eleanor b.1776;
(
9) David 1778-1797;
(
10) Sarah 1781-1855;
(
11) Catherine b.1784.
(1) Sarah b.1793;
(
2) Jonathan 1800-1885;
(
3) Charles 1808-1898;
(
4) Margaret b.1817;
(1) Martha b.177x;
(
2) Elizabeth 1775-1853.  [CB]
(1) Joanna b.178x;
(
2) Stephan Day b.1787;
(
3) Mary Foster b.1789;
(
4) Julia 1790-1856;
(
5) Barney 1799-1868.  [CB]
  {1, 3, 4, 7 above married Coovers}        
Parents: ?? *Capt Nathaniel Bonnell (1696-1763)  &  Joanna Miller   [CB] Lt Col Abraham Bonnell (1732-1797)  &  Elizabeth Foster Capt Anthony Bonnell (1685-1743)  &  Margaret Harriet Horry Capt Benjamin Bonnel (1723-1798) & Rachel van Winkle [CB]
           
Siblings:
(#) column subj;
(1) John_1 1754-1845;
??
*(1) Benjamin Capt 1723-1798;
(
2) Jane 1725-1735;
(
3) Mary 1730-1811;
*(
4) Nathaniel Capt 1731-1809;
(
5) Abigail 1735-1824;
(
6) Elizabeth 1737-1809;
(7) John_2 1737-1817;
(
8) Sarah 1741-1822.
(1) Mary V 1760-1760;
(2) John_3 1762-1823;
(
3)Jeremiah 1763-1763;
(
4) Clement DuMont 1766-1836;
(
5) Alexander 1768-1819;
(
6) Newell 1770-1793;
(
7) Charles Foster 1781-1847;
(
8) Abraham b.1783.
(1) John_4 1753-1810;
??

(1) Joanna b.1746;
(
2) Jane b.1748;
(
3) Nathaniel b.175x;
(
4) Benjamin 1751-1808;
(
5) Samuel 1755-1816;
(6) John_5 1757-184x;
(7) Aaron 1759-1837;
(
8) Rachel 1760-1797;
(
9) Paul 1762-1820;
(
10) Sarah b.1765;
(
11) Rhoda b.1767;
(
12) Abigail 1769-1859;  
(13) Mary b.1772;          [CB]
           
CB DB#:    CB004113 CB300181 CB310033 CB003076 CB310240
Austin A#: n/a p.148  A#13127 p.164:C2 n/a p.143:C7
           
SAR Info: www.sar.org  John Bonnell, B 1757 NJ., D. 1845 Pa., Wife Nancy Pandy, Son John Bonnell Jr. Serv. Sgt. Pa Mil, SAR member William Bonnell Emery, ANC #077998 Pa#05751        
           
           
DAR Info: BONNELL, JOHN Ancestor #: A011987   Service: PA
Rank: SERGEANT 
Birth: (CIRCA) 1757 IRELAND   Death: (CIRCA) 1845 WATERFORD TWP. ERIE CO PA  
Service Description:   1) ALSO PVT CAPTS.MANNING,RUTHERFORD STUART, 2) COL. JAMES BURD MILITIA.    
Residence:
  1) PAXTON - LANCASTER CO. - PA 
SpouseNo. Name:
 
1) NANCY PANDY/PANKEY 
Desc SON: JOHN, JR. / [1] CATHERINE MILLER  
BONNELL, JOHN Ancestor #: A011986   Service: NJ   
Rank: PATRIOTIC SERVICE    Birth: 26 Sep 1737    ELIZABETH ESSEX CO NEW JERSEY   Death: 15 Dec 1817    SPRINGFIELD TWP. ESSEX CO NEW JERSEY  
Service Description: 1) PAID FOR SERVICE   
Residence: 1) SPRINGFIELD TWP. - ESSEX CO. - NEW JERSEY
SpouseNo. Name
 
1) SARAH CARTER 
BONNELL, JOHN Ancestor #: A200147   Service: CONTINENTAL LINE   
 Rank:
PRIVATE    
Birth: 
1762     HUNTERDON CO NEW JERSEY   Death: 1 Apr 1823    HARRISON CO VIRGINIA   
Service Source: S*W6222 BLW #6891-100-7 (He received pension as did his wife when he died)   
Service Description: 1) CAPT THOMAS MACHIN, COL JOHN LAMB, ARTL 2ND REGT   Residence: 1) HUNTERDON CO - NEW JERSEY  
SpouseNo. Name
 1) HANNAH SMITH  
 
2) RHULANA FITZRANDOLPH 
BONNELL, JOHN Ancestor #: A011985   Service: GEORGIA    Rank: LIEUTENANT  
Birth: (ANTE) 1753     Death: (ANTE) 16 Mar 1810    SCREVEN CO GEORGIA  
Residence: 1) SCREVEN CO. - GEORGIA  
SpouseNo. Name
 1) WINNEFORD Unknown 
 
           
rev. war-pensions Since John_1 did NOT request a Pension, there is not much info at National Archives in Washington, DC.       bonnell, john, n.j. line applied 27 may 1833 in wayne co., pa aged 76, resident of dyberry twp. enlisted in essex co co., n.j. and also drafted in morris co., n.j. where he lived. soldier was born march 1757 in essex co., n.j. and in 1816 moved to pa.   [gb] genforum.genealogy.com/americanrev/messages/15015.html
           
Other reference documents Military involvement documented in Pennsylvania Archives, Series 5, V.II, p.482, 506, 990;  V.III, p.846; V.VII, p.346, 388, 398, 403, 998, 1023, 1031.        
  May be the John Bendal in the Dauphin Co, 1790 Census
(REEL#: M637-8):
39 42 BENDAL John 1 2 2 . .
      http://www.rootsweb.com/~pawayne/1830census.htm ;
Dyberry Township, p.204
Bunnell, John
Not found in 1850 Census

name variations: Bonnel, Bunnell, Bunnel, Bunel, Bunhill, Bendal, Bonsal, Bundle, ...      
Internet sites: